← The Trouble ClefBrowse 2020 ↗

Originally published on December 10, 2020 on the now-defunct Best American Poetry blog. Republished in The Trouble Clef.

Illustration accompanying Beethoven's Choice

The truth is that I do not know how I feel about Beethoven.

There seem to be two separate things: Beethoven and our admiration for Beethoven. The second has become so imposing that it is difficult to find the first.

Just try to move the world’s admiration aside. What will you see in its place? The admiration seems to be made of bronze: it can acquire any patina or color, yet it is too heavy to lift. It seems to have replaced Beethoven forever. The man has become insignificant beside what he symbolizes: greatness, freedom, the best of humanity.

Was the real Beethoven the best of humanity? Can we still ask?

I suspect there is something awkward about Beethoven. We admire him because he can rise above his squareness, his grumpiness, his inability to fly easily. He triumphs over his limitations, and perhaps that is why he feels closer to us than Mozart with his divine ease.

Beethoven is a lion who tears music with his teeth, claws, and sforzandi. Through the efforts of his stubborn will, he can roar triumphantly at the end. We celebrate his brow; we celebrate his sweat. We forgive his bad manners, his cruelties. None of it matters.

We even forgive him for making a choir wait through most of the Ninth Symphony before it can sing.

Or perhaps forgiveness has nothing to do with it. Perhaps we have placed him beyond its reach.

When a man becomes a god, he sheds his humanity along with his life.

Godliness, like anything else, requires sacrifice.

Was that Beethoven’s choice?

Illustration accompanying Beethoven's Choice
Beethoven's Death Mask

← Return to The Trouble Clef

Explore all 111 entries ↗
#

Comments are closed